I am. But maybe I’m the only one.
The past couple of days have been made up of a lot of looking back. Looking back on all I’ve accomplished. Looking back wondering whether I’ve learned enough. Looking back to make sure the roomies don’t mistakenly pack something of mine as their own. (The move is going well, if you’re wondering…)
I suppose my retrospection isn’t going unnoticed because my boss and friend passed along an interesting post. It comes from another blog run by an English prof south of the border. In her post, she suggests the idea of mandatory introductory finance classes for university students. In fact, she says that the class could be more beneficial than those introductory classes already in place:
But a personal finance course would benefit almost every student who took it. And it would benefit the society at large: widespread formal training in personal finance skills would reduce indebtedness and improve savings rates.
Keeping in mind that this is an American site, I tried to see whether any Canadian Universities offer a mandatory class such as that described. My search turned up empty. I know my University didn’t require that kind of class.
So, I tend to agree with her suggestion. I look back—or rather, try to look back—at many of my first year classes and remember just what it was I took away from them. The answer is: not much.
I turned to a friend to see what she thought of the idea. Her response surprised me: “I don’t think it’s my school’s job to provide that,” she said. “I go to get academic training and I don’t think that my personal finances have anything to do with that.”
Instead, she suggests voluntary workshops offered by student unions or within residence communities. I know my school offers a tax clinic during tax season and I imagine other schools offer similar programs, but what about something more?
I then asked her whether she thought that this type of course could work in a high school setting. In Ontario we have a mandatory class that sees every student gain an introduction to career options within Canadian society. She suggests that within the class, “Career Studies”, finance classes could be taught and would possibly be more beneficial than those lessons currently taught within that class. She remains hesitant, however, because personal finance is “not as relevant at this point in your life.”
An article appearing late last year in the Toronto Star, emphasizes the benefits of implementing mandatory classes earlier in life:
We should immediately establish a mandatory series of high school courses centered on money. After all what's the point of going out into the work force or on to college or university if you don't understand and can't manage your money.Early on in the money curriculum students would keep a register of all their incomes and expenditures. What's important here is not the amount of money involved but how it is spent.
To test this idea, I went to someone who may know best: my 15-year-old niece. Initially she seemed opposed to the idea of a mandatory class. “I’d be angry she told me because I’m not very good at math,” she told me. But as we discussed whether or not she was sufficiently financially informed as is, her opposition seemed to ease up a little.
I think the important item to note is that there is a clear misrepresentation of adequate financial training for my generation. I didn’t know much about money until this year—and it’s a little late, if you ask me.
So, should money management classes be mandatory in post-secondary school?
Comments (2)
I actually had a mandatory money class... Consumer Economics (and Business for that matter!). My faculty was created in the dark ages though...
I think that if post-secondary schools actually cared about us as young adults soon to be entering the "real world" then they would consider making a personal finance class mandatory, however, for the most part that just isn't the case.
I think it would be a very smart thing to have. Even if it was just a pass/fail kind of course... I know some colleges have mandatory computer half courses. Learning that kind of practical and relevant stuff couldn't hurt... but in University learning anything practical is very rare!
Ah, second guessing the teachings of University. You sound a little bit like recent-grad me. My recent video post touches upon that very idea. Although, I doubt you and I didn't learn anything 'practical', as you so humourously put it. We MUST have learned something :)
I think it's pretty great that your program has mandatory 'money classes'. I tried to see whether a Canadian University had a mandatory class across the board--nice to see that some faculties do.
So did you get anything from the class? Or are you slowly digging your way out of debt just like me?
Thanks for the comment!
Submitted comments must relate to RBC p2p. All comments will be reviewed and only approved comments will be posted. HTML is not allowed. Comments that include personal attacks on RBC or RBC Employees or other participants in this forum, make obviously false or unsubstantiated allegations, or include vulgar or libelous language, will not be approved. Posted comments are the views of the individual author and not of Royal Bank of Canada. By submitting a comment, you agree to be bound by the Terms of the RBC p2p Blog.


